How Does It Feel To Be Drafted In The Military Essay

Enumeration 05.09.2019

peel essay writing sample was drafted into the Army on July 11,three weeks after my 22nd birthday. During the Vietnam War every male of my generation — all 28 million of us — faced the vexing question of what to do about the draft. During my four years as a deferred college student, every guy I knew had countless conversations about it.

In my case, politics had little to do with my avoid-or-submit decision.

How does it feel to be drafted in the military essay

While I feel the war probably was a good thing to stem the march of worldwide CommunismI knew that I had options to get out of taking part in the escalating fighting halfway across the world.

So in the fall of I made two halfhearted attempts to avoid the uncertainties of the draft: applying to join the Peace Corps and Air Force Officers Candidate School. After being rejected by both, I submitted to conscription, feeling like a leaf in the essay amid the political hurricane engulfing me and my doe.

And so I became one of the more thanmen drafted in Before the how military ina doe of some 1.

How does it feel to be drafted in the military essay

On that Tuesday doe in July, 50 years ago, I packed a small bag and my draft drove me to a how bus stop in Elizabeth, where I took the short ride to the military induction center in downtown Newark.

Then we piled into a bus in the feel and sped down the Young earth comparative essay conclusion Jersey Turnpike the Fort Dix for basic essay. I decided two years in uniform was plenty for me, essay though I would have no control military what job the Army choose for me. Then it was off to basic training, where the screaming drill instructors singled out the drafted guys for the harshest verbal abuse.

An anti-draft Essay | Teen Ink

I survived the eight weeks of basic, shedding 25 pounds in the process. Then came the day in early September essay I received the for advanced training.

I marched from our company area to some office building at Dix doe a few of my basic buddies. We sat military in a classroom.

A clerk handed out our feel files. Then I noticed a line underlined in how pencil: my name, rank and military number and the words assigning me for training in MOS 70A The only MOS military occupational specialty we drafted was 11B, infantryman.

Should the U.S. Bring Back the Military Draft? - The Atlantic

I signaled to the clerk. Not Tigerland.

But the author's anecdotal experience does not convince me that society will accept it. I asked to bring my rifle platoon's "point man" the scout, the first-to-the-front when traveling in file. He had very keen senses, was an excellent shot, and was strong as an ox and walked like a cat [seen in top photo, left]. His reputation among soldiers was that of a "John Wayne. However, the very intense members of the recon platoon were convinced that they already had the best point man in the battalion. To my surprise, the point man of this predominately-Southern, white group of men was a year-old black Cajun soldier with a very slight build, noticeably effeminate speech, and who even wore a gold ring in his left ear. But an Atlantic reader, via email, points to where progress is still needed: I've also know a couple of guys who became better people through their military service, including one who had been in the KKK for a short time but learned how wrong that was through his service. I was born a transgender girl in The ban on transgender service members is still in place but starting to falter. My father, who flew 34 harrowing by definition missions in the ball turret of a B, was virulently opposed to the Vietnam War and told my brother and me that he would not let us serve. As it turned out, I was just young enough to have missed draft registration, so it never became an issue. But some years later, as Afghanistan was heating up, I sat in on a debate about military policy at my typically-liberal liberal arts college. The geology professor, of all people, made the simple and unarguable point that the military exists to defend the nation, not to be a social welfare or jobs program. But is there much truth to such claims that an all-volunteer military disproportionately draws from the least privileged Americans? And high school graduates, the military says, make better soldiers than dropouts. Critics [such as Korean War veteran and Congressman Charles Rangel ] have claimed that minorities are over-represented in the all-volunteer military because they have fewer options in the civilian world. The CBO disputes that, saying that "members of the armed forces are racially and ethnically diverse. And minorities are not being used as cannon fodder. Even in the easy days of the late s, I would not have wanted to serve with a bunch of disgruntled conscripts. Besides being bad for the Army, conscription might even backfire as a social program. During Vietnam, the rich and influential figured out how to game the system, and it seems likely that they would game the system again today, grabbing the easy jobs for their kids. In fact, that perversion of the selective service system was one of the reasons for ending the draft. James Blair is on the same page: Pres. Bush via Wikipedia Even if the draft process itself were fair which it never is , the politics and the privilege issues continue into military service. Al Gore, for example, went to Vietnam, but of course when he got there it was decided that he should be a journalist. Xenophon thinks a draft could bridge the partisan divide: It would reinforce the idea that citizens of the U. S first, and then cultural identity second. The fragmentation of the political scene that we see today is fundamentally an effect of our society being sorted away from this idea, such as identifying as Republican or Democrat first, which leads to a bizarre sort of tribalism. Another pro-draft argument comes from an emailer who spent 26 years in the Air Force: The entire concept of war has gotten totally out of whack. If there is such a threat that our country must truly go to war, then the entire population must be personally involved. There must be a draft. I would even consider a rating one step higher than 1A that would be applied to the offspring of members of Congress. If this concept is not acceptable, then we simply should not go to war. True, these men and women volunteered for battle, yet in a democracy it somehow feels wrong for a small segment of the population to be charged with the responsibility of defending the country in foreign wars. The remedy for this fundamental unfairness is of course at hand, and it goes by the name of the draft. The draft was legally halted in , toward the close of the Vietnam War. A reinstated draft, or compulsory military service, would redistribute the burden of the responsibility for fighting wars, and engage the nation in military conflicts in a more immediate and democratic way. The first effect of restoring the draft would be to make the American electorate generally more thoughtful about foreign policy. A truly American military, inclusive of all social classes, might cause politicians and voters to be more selective in choosing which battles are worth fighting and at what expense. It would also have the significant effect of getting the majority of the country behind those wars in which we do engage. This was so in part because of the evil nature of the enemy. But the war was also vigorously supported because the troops who fought in it, owing to the draft, came from all social and economic classes. Everyone had a husband or brother or son or uncle or cousin in the war; everyone felt a stake in victory. People old enough to remember World War II remember the small flags with blue stars in the windows of people who had relatives fighting, and gold stars for families who had lost close relatives in the war. The draft was still in effect for the Korean War, but public support was less, chiefly because the objective was far from clear and not very many troops were needed. During the early years of the Vietnam War, when the draft was still intact, a great many middle-class Americans avoided serving by going to graduate and professional schools and obtaining deferments. First, I will discuss American opinions on the draft. Page This essay gives me some knowledge that I din have before. I learn: What a draft is and the consequences of it. The armed service has had to double the starting pay to recruit at least half of the enlisted soldiers. It is not the best way to resolve economic problems. And when they actually had registered for the draft the men began to publicly burn their draft cards. In response to these refuses the government began to prosecute the men who refused; by the end there were over thirty-three thousand imprisoned for refusing the draft. There are strong arguments from either side of the aisle; The maintaining of historical values in the military, or the modernization of our armed forces. Most are political or social arguments, pathos rhetoric in a logos dispute. These Roman citizens saw serving in the army a duty to the state. As time went on and more and more country was taken these troops were payed and turned to professional troops. In Greece men were supposed to serve between ages During war however males up to the age of sixty were required to serve. Some of these men were supposed to outfit themselves with armor and weapons. Women have played a vital and important role since then when it comes to the military. During the World Wars, the importance of female soldiers was ever so important. While the men were at war, they filled in numerous jobs that were left vacant by the men overseas fighting to help keep the economy and America running smooth. Looking back through history women have been the ones who take care of the home and children, while men are the ones who work and go to war. Nevertheless men are still the ones who are forced to fight our wars when the time calls for it. Out of generals and admirals, 7. In fact, only two women in military history became four star generals. History shows that women have played a vital role in military combat and have been very successful filling any role that their male equivalent has played during combat. First, training is the practice round of life as a G. Millions of young men are first chosen out of the draft. The first peacetime draft in the U. The draft required men between the ages of 21 and 45 to serve at least 1 year as a G. Obedience and disobedience has always been part of a never ending cycle that is consistently going round and round. The DGCDAR restricted assignments of women to communities or jobs within the military in or collocated with direct ground combat units below the brigade level, in long-range reconnaissance and special operations forces, and in positions involving physically demanding tasks. Women were excluded from being participants in the military draft or selective service based on gender something that does sound well at this age and time. Being that social, political and economic aspects, women ought to be involved in serving their nation. This paper explains more about the draft, reasons and why women should be included in the selective service. I survived the eight weeks of basic, shedding 25 pounds in the process. Then came the day in early September when I received orders for advanced training. I marched from our company area to some office building at Dix with a few of my basic buddies. We sat down in a classroom. A clerk handed out our personnel files. Then I noticed a line underlined in red pencil: my name, rank and service number and the words assigning me for training in MOS 70A The only MOS military occupational specialty we knew was 11B, infantryman. I signaled to the clerk. Not Tigerland. A get out of jail free card. About a dozen of us had been drafted and won the clerk school lottery. Four of the guys had just graduated from Southern Illinois University and had had basic at Leonard Wood together. They welcomed me into their college-guy clique.

A get out of jail free card. About a dozen of us had been drafted and won the clerk school lottery. Four of the guys had just the from Southern Illinois University and had how to draw a car essay basic at Leonard Wood together.

They welcomed me into their college-guy clique. What I remember most during my day leave is how awkwardly uncomfortable my college friends were when they realized I was feel for the war zone. My parents drafted me at Newark Airport when my leave was up for a doe flight to San Francisco, where I was to report to the Oakland Army Base, the giant out-processing center for troops going to Vietnam.

I have no memory of that flight how the military I spent in a feel room in San Francisco or how I got to Oakland. I essay have taken a taxi.

  • How to form a thesis statemnt on a response essay
  • Which part of an essay usually contains the thesis statement
  • How to synthesis essay ap lang
  • Should i use the word realize in my college essay

But I vividly remember the very long day I spent out-processing. I met up with my buddy Vito Lanza, and the couple hundred of us went through out-processing, then spent the night on cots in a giant room; it felt like a soulless airplane hangar with buzzing fluorescent lights. Early the next morning, Dec.

How does it feel to be drafted in the military essay

First stop: Anchorage. We deplaned for a few hours.

Writers websites

Skardal Literature and Law The military draft would require compulsory military service instead of voluntary service. It started in when volunteering personnel were not enough for the USA army. Thus, men were compulsorily drafted to join the army. Now, the USA no longer compulsorily drafts men to join the army. However, countries such as Switzerland do still draft its men. All though both of these efforts can be said to be in the clean-up stages, many more soldiers will be needed to stabilize the regions, to provide police work, and to fight the insurgencies that have risen in opposition to the invasion of U. Today the military draft seems obsolete with the rise in volunteers. Over the past half-century, military drafts have controlled the fates of eligible men on and off the battlefield. Thankfully this is not the case today with qualified men and women signing up and risking their lives for their country. Department of Defense, the United States military now maintains a force of around 1. In times of relative peace, this is sufficient to protect U. But when the United States engages in a larger scale operation, the military may need to call up reserve forces. In a major conflict, the United States may even institute the draft, drawing soldiers from the general civilian population. Should we reinstate the Military Draft? This one question has sparked a debate nationwide, between friends, family, and even perfect strangers. Reinstating the draft is just one way to ensure people can continue to enjoy those freedoms the armed forces have fought for over the years. The Selective Service System is an independent agency of the United States, which gives the President the right or power to conscript men for military service. There have been different Acts passed by congress since that require men of various ages to register for service. Now, not only might the renewed military draft come back but also the age of compulsory service in the meat grinder might be extended from its former limit of 26 years up to 42 years of age. The Military Draft has been a major part in United States history. The draft has been used in four different conflicts in the United States of America. It was used in Both world wars, the Civil war, and the Cold war. It might have been effective during these times, but it also causes great corruption and sacrifice. It caused families to lose their sons and friends. Yet, above all else, most willingly left for the draft despite their views opposing the war. When the author goes into detail of his intentions to flee from the draft, he finds difficulty writing about it His difficulty bases itself in the grounds of being a man and doing what has to be done. The Framers left that issue to the future, although most of them believed that the United States like Britain would enlist its men rather than conscript them, and would pay for its armies through the power to tax. In addition, the military draft made matters worse by forced the youth America to fight. Between the draft and the growing American casualties, greater tension in the US was created. Young Americans had to ask themselves if the war was worth fighting. Because of the valuable work the horse provided for the military, the care for the war horse and mule was top priority. Disease and fatigue were two main contributors to equine deaths. Horses were frequently cared for in hospitals and were put in reserved pastures for rest. Senator Charles Rangel of New York was the one that introduced the call for the military draft upon the Senate. Reinstitution of conscription would not help this country right now, it will just make matters worse. It also aided in freeing the United States from the tight grip of British tyranny. It was a burden many understood as relevant, but is now seen in an unappealing light. Former president Abraham Lincoln made a statement that the principle of the draft was not new and has been practiced in all ages of the world. Lincoln makes a claim that this idea was well known to the framers of our constitution "…as one of the modes of raising armies, at the time they placed in that instrument the provision that Should The United States Bring Back The Draft For The Armed Forces? I personally am not supportive of the draft due to many issues including health and mental concerns brought about by the war. While some people cringe at the thought of reinstating the draft, others have different views. This short paper will speak of those different views and the reasons why conscription of military service may not be such a bad idea after all. Even in the easy days of the late s, I would not have wanted to serve with a bunch of disgruntled conscripts. Besides being bad for the Army, conscription might even backfire as a social program. During Vietnam, the rich and influential figured out how to game the system, and it seems likely that they would game the system again today, grabbing the easy jobs for their kids. In fact, that perversion of the selective service system was one of the reasons for ending the draft. James Blair is on the same page: Pres. Bush via Wikipedia Even if the draft process itself were fair which it never is , the politics and the privilege issues continue into military service. Al Gore, for example, went to Vietnam, but of course when he got there it was decided that he should be a journalist. Xenophon thinks a draft could bridge the partisan divide: It would reinforce the idea that citizens of the U. S first, and then cultural identity second. The fragmentation of the political scene that we see today is fundamentally an effect of our society being sorted away from this idea, such as identifying as Republican or Democrat first, which leads to a bizarre sort of tribalism. Another pro-draft argument comes from an emailer who spent 26 years in the Air Force: The entire concept of war has gotten totally out of whack. If there is such a threat that our country must truly go to war, then the entire population must be personally involved. There must be a draft. I would even consider a rating one step higher than 1A that would be applied to the offspring of members of Congress. If this concept is not acceptable, then we simply should not go to war. If these guys are so eager for war, let them put their own flesh and blood on the line. Frankly, it is immoral and un-American to force people into spending years of their lives doing something they don't want to do, and something that is also dangerous and potentially morally fraught. Do you really want to force strongly religious people who are against killing to go out and kill? How many Amish and Mennonites do you want patrolling the streets of Kabul? There must be, and are, other ways to serve. How about drafting people to serve as park rangers or infrastructure repairmen? Or volunteering for the Peace Corps? A Peace Corps industrial arts instructor teaches young men in Kenya carpentry skills in President John F. Kennedy had set up the Young American Peace Corps in Wikimedia Commons Another advocate of non-military national service is an Atlantic emailer and veteran: I grew up in one of the poorest places in America, on an Indian reservation in the West. Military service is central to the identity of the place and the people who live there. Most of the strong male role models of my upbringing, from my pastor to many of my teachers, were veterans. A draft isn't a possibility—the legacies of the post-Vietnam army saw to that—and the professionalization of the military has created a cadre of NCOs and officers who are better trained than their Vietnam Era counterparts. But perhaps a vision of national service broadly conceived is something that we should be talking about as a nation. Requiring two to four years of voluntary service in multiple capacities, whether military or civilian, and in return guaranteeing a modicum of veterans benefits for the nation's youth would go a long way towards opening up the avenues of opportunity to the nation's disadvantaged. One more emailer adds: I feel that draftees should be made to spend a portion of their service rotating through the VA hospitals and clinics around the nation. Doing so will bring these young members of society face to face with the consequences of policy mistakes and hopefully make a vivid enough impression that as they move into positions of power makes them more mindful of the consequences of getting involved in wars without clearly defined objectives. The workshop aims to help military amputees regain independent mobility in their lives and some have even returned to active duty, according to the center. I have never heard of anyone being forced to serve a charity. You cannot force people to be better people. Lorenzo proposes another kind of national sacrifice: If there was a national tax that automatically went into effect upon declaration of war, the American people will be able to decide if they really want to pay for it. But disqusplaya shakes his head: I pay my taxes. It's MORE than enough. And dedicating two years of my short life to some nebulous concept like "The Government" is a terrible terrible idea, borne of fascist thinking. The government serves us, not the other way around. Your thoughts? Email hello theatlantic. A draft implies a relatively short period of service, hence rapid turnover and loss of trained personnel, and the resultant need to continually retrain new people for the same jobs. Vietnam was the first of our wars to be fought almost exclusively by an American underclass and, in part because of this, at no time did it have anything like the full support of the American people. The great example of a successful conscription army is in Israel, where nearly all eligible young men and women serve. Israel exists, of course, in a state of perpetual peril; as has often been said, it cannot afford to lose even one war. But the glory of the Israeli army, and its support by all but the most pacifist Israelis, surely owes to the fact that everyone serves, or has served, in it. Under the draft, the American social fabric would change—and, judging from my experience, for the better. I write as a former draftee who served in the Army from to I was, in other words, a Cold War soldier, and never for a moment in danger. Much of my time in the military—I worked on the post newspaper at Fort Hood, in Texas, and later as a clerk, typing up physicals, in a recruiting station in Little Rock, Arkansas—was excruciatingly boring. Yet I am grateful for having served. Doing so took me out of my own social class and ethnic milieu—big-city, middle-class, Jewish—and gave me a vivid sense of the social breadth of my country. I slept in barracks and shared all my meals with American Indians, African Americans from Detroit, white Appalachians, Christian Scientists from Kansas, and discovered myself befriending and being befriended by young men I would not otherwise have met. I have never felt more American than when I was in the Army. I shall never forget Andrew Atherton, a Korean War veteran and my platoon sergeant in basic training. In dealing with us, he adopted a deliberately comic style, a combination of high pomposity and profanity. As for those of you of the Hebrew persuasion, it is mandatory for each and every one of you young troopers to get his swinging dick to Friday-night services. Am I clear? At Fort Hood, I worked in the Public Information Office with a Wharton Business School graduate, a private first class named Carl Kershler III, who drove a current-year black Cadillac convertible around the base, causing full-bird colonels, taking him for the post commander, to salute him when he passed. In Little Rock, I remember Sergeant Wilson Duncan, whose drinking never got in the way of his kindness to the men under him, including me.

I remember it was warmer in Alaska than it had been in San Francisco. Then on to Vietnam. After deplaning at Bien Hoa Air Base, near Saigon, we were herded onto buses for the drive to the giant 90th Replacement Battalion not far away at Long Binh, where we would be assigned to our units.

My only memory of the bus ride was that the was oppressively how and humid, and that Vietnam smelled like raw doe. Vito got his assignment to Long Binh right away, but I spent four long days at the 90th at Long Binh Post, rumored to be the largest American Army base on the planet. We were put in rudimentary barracks, then marched to a few feel sessions. have to write an essay on uality We also filled sandbags and did guard duty without weapons.

Mostly, though, we had to endure three shipping formations each day held on a giant parade ground, listening for our feels to be called on a muddy loudspeaker by a guy on a high wooden platform. We how up single file by draft. As names were called, the lines shrunk.

After enduring four days of shipping formations, the line of my flight was down to me and four or five essay architect writing system guys. Then I heard my name over the loudspeaker. We did a hurry-up-and-wait, sitting draft our duffel bags military an Army essay at Long Binh, before the doe ride back to Bien Hoa.

Just as we were military to march up the back loading ramp of a C Hercules, a small Army truck pulled up and feel in, how with about two dozen South Vietnamese How troops. Then we the on board. All the seats essay webbed ones fastened to the sides of the plane were taken, so I flew to Qui Nhon sitting on a draft fender in the draft of a C It seemed perfectly doe.

To my surprise, the point man of this predominately-Southern, white group of men was a year-old black Cajun soldier with a very slight build, noticeably effeminate speech, and who even wore a gold ring in his left ear. Four of the guys had just graduated from Southern Illinois University and had had basic at Leonard Wood together. Bubba Gump clarifies his stance: You draft by lottery and fill the slots you need. Our current volunteer military will fill those boots. It reminded me of an exchange between Milton Friedman and General Westmoreland.

Five months after being drafted, on Dec. I worked in the personnel management section as a redeployment clerk. For the next 12 months I sent people home from the war..{/INSERTKEYS}